8 photos Margaritaville Island Hotel
The highest-rated stay in Pigeon Forge on our board: 9.2/10 across 2,530 guest reviews.
Short answer: 10 properties in Pigeon Forge are listed with a pool, with the exact room type to book, guest scores and an indicative nightly range for each (researched monthly). Every card names the exact room type to book, and our research team confirms amenities directly with properties, market by market.
8 photos ✓Jacuzzi in the room Our pick in Pigeon Forge: Margaritaville Island Hotel. It holds a 9.2/10 guest score across 2,530 reviews, more guest reviews than any other stay here.
Showing 10 of 10 stays
8 photos The highest-rated stay in Pigeon Forge on our board: 9.2/10 across 2,530 guest reviews.
8 photos Book the Superior Jr Suite with Fireplace and Jacuzzi. That's the room with the in-room jetted tub. Guests rate it exceptional: 2,465 reviews on the board.
8 photos Book the 1 King Bed Deluxe Studio Suite with Whirlpool. That's the room with the in-room jetted tub. Guests rate it very good: 2,429 reviews on the board.
7 photos Book the Guest Room with Whirlpool. That's the room with the in-room jetted tub. Guests rate it exceptional: 1,614 reviews on the board.
6 photos Book the Suite with Two Queen Beds, Fireplace and Spa Bath. That's the room with the in-room jetted tub. Guests rate it very good: 1,255 reviews on the board.
10 stays on this list · from $56/night
8 photos ✓Indoor pool Book the Upgraded King Suite with Jacuzzi. That's the room with the in-room jetted tub. Guests rate it very good: 876 reviews on the board.
8 photos ✓Jacuzzi in bedroom Book the King Suite with Hot Tub. That's the room with the in-room jetted tub. Guests rate it good: 416 reviews on the board.
7 photos Book the Queen Suite with Whirlpool bathtub. That's the room with the in-room jetted tub. Guests rate it very good: 317 reviews on the board.
8 photos Book the Queen Suite with Spa Bath. That's the room with the in-room jetted tub. Guests rate it exceptional: 213 reviews on the board.
The crowd favorite in Pigeon Forge: 1,396 guest reviews and counting.
Pigeon Forge runs along one long Parkway strip at the edge of Great Smoky Mountains National Park, and the weather is why indoor pools matter here: winters are cold, summer afternoons storm, and families book the pool as the backup plan for a rained-out park day. Most properties are mid-rise motor hotels and resorts where the pool deck is a headline amenity, not an afterthought.
Every stay above is scored against the five checks our founder built from nearly a decade in the hotel industry, and named for the room that actually delivers, not the room in the brochure.
Rates are indicative ranges from published pricing, refreshed October 2026, live prices appear on the booking page. Our research team calls and emails properties to confirm amenities directly; a stay earns its place here only when that confirmation is on file. Imagery shows the destination and the amenity until licensed property photography lands. How we judge and verify →
Computed from the PoolsideStays dataset, research pass October 2026, figures our research team compiles from the property records themselves, published nowhere else in this form. How we judge and verify →
We list 10 properties in Pigeon Forge, each with its room type, guest scores and indicative range on the card. The count grows as our research team works new properties, every page is stamped with its latest research month.
Each listing starts from the property's own published record, the amenity, the exact room type, the guest scores, and our research team confirms listings directly with properties by email and phone. On this page the checked fact is the water itself: 6 of the 10 stays also keep an indoor pool. A listing earns its place here when that confirmation lands, and the card prints the room or unit name that carries the amenity, that name is the contract.
Margaritaville Island Hotel, 2,530 guest reviews, scoring 9.2/10. Review volume is a popularity signal, not a quality guarantee; it is one of the factors we show on every card.
The lowest indicative rate on this page is from $56/night at Colonial House Motel. Rates move daily; the live price for your dates appears when you tap View deal.
Private, on this page, means the water belongs to your room alone. 10 of the stays here keep the tub inside the room itself, a jetted or soaking tub behind your own door. Our pick, Margaritaville Island Hotel, book the Village One Bedroom Suite with Balcony and Whirlpool, is the clearest example. Where a tub is shared with the whole hotel, our cards never give it the private label.
10 stays on this list · from $56/night